Alien Life Could Be Hiding Out on Far Fewer Planets Than We Thought
By Laura Geggel, Associate Editor | June 10, 2019
Where is complex alien life hanging out in the universe? Likely not on planets stewing in toxic gases, according to a new study that dramatically reduces the number of worlds where scientists will have the best luck finding ET.
In the past, researchers defined the “habitable zone” based on the distance between the planet and its star; planets that, like Earth, orbit at just the right distance to accommodate temperatures in which liquid water could exist on the planetary surface would be considered “habitable.” But while this definition works for basic, single-celled microbes, it doesn’t work for complex creatures, such as animals ranging from sponges to humans, the researchers said.
When these extra parameters — needed for complex creatures to exist — are taken into account, this habitable zone shrinks substantially, the researchers said. For instance, planets with high levels of toxic gases, such as carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide, would drop off the master list.
“This is the first time the physiological limits of life on Earth have been considered to predict the distribution of complex life elsewhere in the universe,” study co-researcher Timothy Lyons, a distinguished professor of biogeochemistry and director of the Alternative Earths Astrobiology Center at the University of California, Riverside (UCR), said in a statement.
To investigate, Lyons and his colleagues created a computer model of the atmospheric climate and photochemistry (a field that analyzes how different chemicals behave under visible or ultraviolet light) on a range of planets. The researchers began by looking at predicted levels of carbon dioxide, a gas that’s deadly at high levels but is also needed to keep temperatures above freezing (thanks to the greenhouse effect) on planets that orbit far from their host stars.
“To sustain liquid water at the outer edge of the conventional habitable zone, a planet would need tens of thousands of times more carbon dioxide than Earth has today,” study lead researcher Edward Schwieterman, a NASA postdoctoral fellow working with Lyons, said in the statement. “That’s far beyond the levels known to be toxic to human and animal life on Earth.
“Once carbon dioxide toxicity is factored into the equation, the traditional habitable zone for simple animal life is sliced in two, the researchers said. For complex life like humans, which is more sensitive to high levels of carbon dioxide, this safe zone shrinks to less than a third of the traditional area, the researchers found.
Complex life (blue) will likely be located in a so-called habitable zone that has the potential for liquid water. Other zones aren’t a promising in the search for life, including regions with toxic buildup of carbon dioxide (yellow) and carbon monoxide (red). These likely uninhabitable zones include exoplanets such as Proxima Centauri b and the TRAPPIST-1 planets e, f and g (black dots).
Under the new parameters, some stars have no safe-for-life zone; that includes Proxima Centauri and TRAPPIST-1, two of the sun’s closest neighbors. That’s because planets around these suns likely have high concentrations of carbon monoxide, the researchers said. Carbon monoxide can bind to hemoglobin in animal blood, and even small amounts of it can be deadly. (Conversely, another recent study argued that carbon monoxide might be a sign of extraterrestrial life, but as Schwieterman put it, “these [planets] would certainly not be good places for human or animal life as we know it on Earth.”)
The new guidelines may help researchers trim the number of planets where signs of alien life look promising, a boon to the field, given that there are almost 4,000 confirmed planets out there that orbit stars other than the sun.
“Our discoveries provide one way to decide which of these myriad planets we should observe in more detail,” study co-researcher Christopher Reinhard, a former UCR graduate student who is now an assistant professor of Earth and atmospheric sciences at the Georgia Institute of Technology, said in the statement. “We could identify otherwise-habitable planets with carbon dioxide or carbon monoxide levels that are likely too high to support complex life.”
The study was published online today (June 10) in The Astrophysical Journal.
Source: Alien Life Could Be Hiding Out on Far Fewer Planets Than We Thought